I wish to address some points raised in a recent article by FMT reader Nisha Sharma entitled “Penang’s Curse”.
Firstly, Nisha writes: First the critics were against the LRT, then the highways, and now, reclamation. The initial complaint was over the use of taxpayers’ money. The state then came up with a plan to build the LRT and highways through revenue earned from reclamation. That, too, is not acceptable.
Nisha is wrong.
Truth is the Penang Government wants taxpayers – not only from Penang, but the entire country – to pay for the building of PIL1. The Penang Government has requested a loan of RM1 billion from the federal government to finance the PTMP, specifically the PIL1 project. Where does the federal government gets its funds? From taxpayers.
In addition, the PIL1 highway will be toll-free, yet its many tunnels and road itself will require maintenance and incur operational costs. Who will bear those costs? The Penang State Government. And where does the Penang State Government gets its funds from ultimately? From taxpayers.
So the initial complaint still stands – taxpayers’ money will be used for the project, no matter what.
Second, Nisha writes: Yes, we do need fish on our dining table but when the bigger players come to the fore with modern facilities to bring in 10 times more catch in half the time and cost, will the traditional fishermen be able to survive?
Again, Nisha is wrong.
Improvements in technology do not equal positive benefits. You don’t need to be an expert to know this. Just watch Wicked Tuna: North vs South, which is airing on National Geographic channel currently, and you will learn that although fishermen have the latest in technology and gadgets, they can only land a single tuna fish per vessel per day. Why? Because of the quota set by the Fisheries Department due to depleted fish stocks. And why are fish stocks depleted? Because of overfishing in previous decades due to improvements in technology!
Hauling 10 times more catch will lead to unsustainable fishing and will cause our oceans to be depleted. What will ensure there are fish in the seas are suitable breeding grounds for fish to spawn and grow till adulthood and management of fisheries that emphasise on sustainability. That means protection of mangrove areas as most fish species caught for our food breed and grow in mangrove areas before moving on to the sea during their adulthood.
Nisha Sharma’s article reflects the mentality of the general public quite accurately. Most Malaysians lack the time and inclination to do a bit more research to understand topics, especially relating to the environment. Consequently this results in knee-jerk responses that focus on simple arguments that do not stand up to scrutiny, and common sense. Many Malaysians want things and results fast, without considering any other factors. Perhaps we have become a consumer society where we always think we – the customer – is right, and that everyone should pander to our wants first and foremost.
As a society, we should try our best to educate ourselves and each other. We should also spend time learning about various topics, not just stick to those that concern us or has a direct impact on us. Otherwise, we’re likely to end up as a self-centred, egocentric and materialistic community.
A society is led by its leaders. In Malaysia, and Penang, for that matter, leadership roles tend to be dominated by political figures. They lead, and most of the time, Malaysians follow. So if Penang is in a rut, then the Penang State Government – and the politicians in it – is to be blamed.
The Penang State Government should provide firm leadership in areas that are important to the sustainability of the state and not champion mega-projects that they deem important for their ‘legacy’.
What is more important to Penangnites – Water supply or an LRT system? The Penang Government has yet to ensure water supply to the state is protected – the Ulu Muda catchment area has yet to be protected, and logging still happens there. Talk of a tri-state effort to protect the region has fallen silent, largely due to the states’ demands that compensation be given by the Federal Government to Kedah.
What’s funny is that the Penang State Government is also asking for RM1 billion from the Federal Government for its road. If the state government is so concerned about securing the water supply from Ulu Muda, shouldn’t they use the RM1 billion to compensate Kedah instead of earmarking it for transport project?
I wholeheartedly agree with Nisha that Penang is in a rut, but I think that the government is the one party that is responsible for putting the state there. After all, they were elected to administer the state.
Instead of concrete plans to boost the state in various aspects such as economy, tourism, industry, agriculture, fishery, social and cultural sectors, the Penang State Government has decided to pour RM46 billion on a single sector – TRANSPORT.
How much is spent to boost Penang’s economy? How much for tourism? How much for agriculture? What about fishery? Social and cultural programmes?
It seems that the transport sector is the most important sector to the Penang State Government, based on amount of investment.
If the Penang State Government can spend RM46 billion on transport sector, common sense would insist that it is spending much more on more important sectors. But it is not.
So much money, so little imagination and creativity in planning and organising. What a shame.
Does it make sense at all?
Penangnites, I am sure that any of you can think of better ways to spend RM46 billion to improve Penang. The Penang government’s best idea currently is to reclaim 3 islands, build an LRT system and a 20km road from north to south of the island.
Can you seriously believe that these 3 projects can help improve your life as a Penangnite? Do share with all of us, especially your fellow Penangnites.
Here’s a challenge for every Penangnite, how would you spend RM46 billion on Penang? I think it’s time for you to tell the state government how to spend your hard-earned money properly.
Mike Tan is a former associate editor of Theantdaily